On Win32 this list is empty and we always get controller added events. On UWP, this list is populated and we don't get controlle added events for currently connected controllers.
We can also ditch the lock in RAWINPUT_JoystickQuit() now that the joystick
subsystem quits drivers in reverse order. There's no chance of a racing call
to RAWINPUT_WindowProc() anymore.
Enabling the RawInput backend causes SDL_XINPUT_Enabled() to return false.
That causes WGI and DInput backends to take ownership of XInput-compatible
controllers, because they think there's no XInput-specific backend enabled.
In WGI's case, it will actually race with RawInput to open the device. By
properly excluding XInput devices from WGI, we can ensure that the sets of
devices managed by WGI and RawInput don't intersect. This makes the race
harmless, since they'll never both go after the same device.
The Xbox One driver stack doesn't propagate the VID/PID down to the
HID devices that end up in the GetRawInputDeviceList() output. This
means we end up matching against the wrong VID/PID and can't properly
exclude Xbox One controllers from WGI.
Fortunately, it is possible to walk back up the device tree to find
the parent with the matching VID/PID.
This removes the CM_Register_Notification code on WinRT. Note
that this API _is_ available to UWP apps as of Windows 10.0.17763
(version 1809, released October 2018), according to:
https://docs.microsoft.com/en-us/uwp/win32-and-com/win32-apis#apis-from-api-ms-win-devices-config-l1-1-1dll
So it might be worth readding with some sort of preprocessor check
for minimum targeted version, or whatever is appropriate for WinRT
development.
It is called from WGI before the normal joystick detection has been run, so it needs to actually enumerate currently connected devices.
We can skip the logic checking for other drivers also supporting this device, because that logic is duplicated from the call site.
- Do not call IDirectInputDevice8_QueryInterface(device, &IID_IDirectInputDevice8,...) on DIRECTINPUTDEVICE8 device
- Get joystick VendorID and ProductID via IDirectInputDevice8_GetProperty(.., DIPROP_VIDPID, ..) call instead of messing with DIDEVICEINSTANCE.guidProduct
- Normalize HID device interface path to upper case for stable operation of XInput check
- Remove useless RawInput calls in SDL_IsXInputDevice() - just check for "IG_" string in HID device interface path that we already have
There shouldn't be any observable behavior changes.
i.e. where the string is known guaranteed to be WCHAR*, in:
- SDL_dinputjoystick.c (WIN_IsXInputDevice): VARIANT->var is BSTR (WCHAR*)
- SDL_rawinputjoystick.c (RAWINPUT_AddDevice): string is WCHAR*
- SDL_windows_gaming_input.c (IEventHandler_CRawGameControllerVtbl_InvokeAdded):
string is WCHAR*
There should be more of these..
Carl Glave
Cameron Gutman
Sam Lantinga
Mathieu Eyraud
Ozkan Sezer
Sylvain
Ryan C. Gordon
Dimitriy Ryazantcev
Ethan Lee